← FXCarbon & sustainability

Carbon, policy & the transition

Last capture 7h 47m ago · 80 captures since 8/31/2026
Carbon price (KRBN)
32.65
-6.45%
Transition spread
-6.71%
Clean energy minus fossil, today
EU gas (TTF)
88.45
+3.57% · drives allowance demand
Headlines captured
89
this capture
Carbon brief
Written 7h 46m ago, anchored on KRBN at 32.65
Balancedpolicy & market backdrop
Carbon proxies gap lower as risk-off overwhelms firmer gas and EU-UK linkage support
KRBN at 32.65 has repriced sharply with EUA and GRN, but the policy signal is mixed rather than clearly bearish: EU-UK ETS linking is medium-term supportive, while COP31 deadlock and broad market deleveraging dominate near-term flows.
Next day
abstain
31.40 - 33.70
61% · by Nov 23
Next 2-3 days
abstain
30.80 - 34.50
60% · by Nov 25
Next week
abstain
30.00 - 35.30
60% · by Nov 29
Next month
abstain
27.75 - 37.75
58% · by Dec 22
Themes, scenarios, key levels & risks
Themes
Compliance carbon selloff is confirmed across proxies (bearish carbon)
KRBN is down 6.45% at 32.65, GRN is down 7.72%, and the listed EUA reference is down 7.82% to 77.44 EUR/tCO2e.
Energy-input signal is price-supportive but being ignored for now (bullish carbon)
Dutch TTF gas is up 3.57% to 88.45 and Henry Hub is up 16.83%, which would normally raise coal-switching emissions risk and EUA demand.
Policy backdrop is mixed: linkage support versus COP failure (two sided)
EU and UK agreed to link carbon markets in 2028, but multiple COP31 headlines report no consensus, collapse risk, and rejection of a deal omitting fossil fuels.
Broad risk-off is swamping climate-specific signals (bearish carbon)
S&P 500 is down 8.61%, ICLN -12.46%, TAN -18.44%, PBW -17.31%, and fossil energy XLE -6.85%, indicating cross-asset liquidation.
Scenarios
bear30%
30.80
Trigger: EUA remains below the post-drop 77-78 EUR/t area, KRBN/GRN redemptions continue, and broad equities stay under pressure.
A continuation leg would reflect forced selling and delayed ETF transmission rather than fresh policy loosening.
base45%
32.80
Trigger: EUA stabilizes near current levels while gas remains firm and no new ETS cost-containment headlines emerge.
After a 6.45% KRBN one-day fall, consolidation around 32-33 is the highest-probability path.
bull25%
34.40
Trigger: Risk assets rebound, EUA retraces part of the 7.82% fall, and markets refocus on EU-UK ETS linkage and high gas prices.
A bounce can be sharp because KRBN is now near the lower edge of recent forecast bands, but conviction is limited.
Key levels
32.65pivotCurrent KRBN anchor after a 6.45% one-day gap lower; all near-term ranges are centered from here.
31.30supportRecent next-day forecast lower band that captured the prior close; a break would signal the selloff is extending beyond recent realized volatility.
34.90resistancePrior close before today’s 6.45% drop; reclaiming it would largely erase the shock move.
30.00band edgeApproximate one-week stress lower edge, about 8% below spot, used to allow for lagged EUA/ETF transmission.
Macro & policy risks
Global equity deleveraging and ETF outflowsbearish carbonhigh
European gas spike and coal-switching riskbullish carbonmedium
ETS affordability or cost-containment political pressurebearish carbonmedium
EU-UK linkage implementation details for 2028two sidedmedium
How the headlines were read
EU and UK Agree to Link Carbon Markets in 2028, With £6.5 Billion of Exports Set for CBAM Relief (bullish carbon)
Linkage supports market depth and policy credibility, though timing is too distant to offset today’s liquidation fully.
UK and EU Agree to Link Emissions Trading Schemes (bullish carbon)
Confirms a structural integration theme for European carbon markets and reduces long-term fragmentation risk.
COP31 climate talks see no consensus as EU, others reject deal (bearish carbon)
Failure to agree a stronger deal weakens global climate-policy momentum, even if EU ETS supply is not directly changed.
UPDATE – COP31: Antalya Pact collapses over fossil fuel omission, carbon capture push (bearish carbon)
A collapsed pact and fossil-fuel omission are negative for transition-policy sentiment and voluntary-market confidence.
Businesses says Labour should fix flaws in Emissions Trading Scheme (bearish carbon)
Industry pressure to fix ETS flaws can translate into political pressure for price relief or design changes.
Co-legislators reach agreement on SFDR 2.0 (neutral)
Disclosure reform matters for ESG flows, but it is not a direct driver of allowance scarcity over the next week.
Full reasoning
KRBN fell 6.45% today, broadly consistent with GRN -7.72% and EUA -7.82%, so this looks like a real carbon/proxy shock rather than only KRBN-specific noise. However, Dutch TTF gas rose 3.57% and Henry Hub rose 16.83%, which normally supports allowance demand through fuel-switching economics. With the S&P 500 down 8.61% and clean-energy ETFs down 9-18%, the immediate driver appears to be macro risk-off and transition-equity liquidation, not a simple loosening of carbon supply.
Calibration: Recent week and 2-3 day ranges were too tight around 33-36, so I widened short horizons after the EUA/KRBN gap lower and kept confidence modest.
Next day: The 6.45% KRBN fall, 7.72% GRN fall, and 7.82% EUA fall argue for a wider-than-normal one-day band; firmer TTF gas offsets a clean directional bearish call.
Next 2-3 days: ETF flow noise and lagged transmission from the EUA move can still matter, while a risk-asset bounce could retrace part of the gap lower.
Next week: The range allows for either a continuation of broad risk-off selling or stabilization if markets refocus on high gas prices and EU-UK ETS linkage.
Next month: Monthly uncertainty is high because policy signals are mixed, COP31 damage is sentiment-heavy, and today’s cross-asset shock may either normalize or deepen.
Track record
Every horizon forecast is marked to the captured price on its target date and scored on direction and range.
Direction hit rate
23.5%
Range hit rate
95.0%
Avg error
1.60%
Streak
1 (best 3)
By horizon (200 graded)
Next day51 graded · direction 37.2% · range 96.1% · error 0.64%
Next 2-3 days51 graded · direction 6.5% · range 92.2% · error 1.47%
Next week51 graded · direction 12.5% · range 92.2% · error 2.11%
Next month47 graded · direction 33.3% · range 100.0% · error 2.24%
Recent graded calls
Next week to Nov 22 · said abstain 33.20-36.40 → actual 32.65 (-6.45%)range miss
KRBN fell to 32.65, below the 33.20 lower end of the forecast range, while the forecast abstained on direction. The stated downside scenario of a reversal if the gas spike faded was directionally relevant, but the one-week range did not allow enough downside in this instance. This is a single ETF-proxy miss and does not by itself establish a repeatable calibration or driver-weighting mechanism.
Next 2-3 days to Nov 22 · said abstain 31.20-34.50 → actual 32.65 (-0.49%)range hit
KRBN finished nearly unchanged at 32.65 versus the 32.81 forecast origin, with the model abstaining on direction. The 31.20-34.50 range captured the outcome, and the midpoint error was small at 0.61%. This single range hit does not reveal a repeatable mechanism or calibration issue.
Next month to Nov 22 · said abstain 30.25-38.50 → actual 32.65 (-4.27%)range hit
KRBN fell 4.27% over the month, while the forecast explicitly abstained on direction and used a broad 30.25-38.50 range. The actual price of 32.65 landed inside the range, with a moderate 5.02% deviation from the midpoint. This outcome is consistent with the stated uncertainty around policy timing, gas dynamics, and ETF proxy-flow noise rather than revealing a forecastable directional mechanism.
Next day to Nov 22 · said abstain 31.70-33.70 → actual 32.65 (0.00%)range hit
KRBN finished exactly unchanged at 32.65, while the forecast abstained on direction and used a widened 31.70-33.70 band. The outcome was well inside the range and near its midpoint, so there is no evidence here of a systematic range-width or driver-weighting error. A single quiet next-day print after volatile proxy moves does not reveal a repeatable mechanism.
Next 2-3 days to Nov 21 · said abstain 33.35-35.35 → actual 32.65 (-5.00%)range miss
KRBN fell sharply to 32.65, below the forecast range of 33.35-35.35. The abstention on direction was consistent with the stated uncertainty from proxy divergence, but the 2-3 day downside move exceeded the expected band. This is only one noisy ETF-proxy outcome, so it does not by itself establish a repeatable range-width or driver-weighting failure.
Next week to Nov 21 · said abstain 33.40-36.45 → actual 32.65 (-6.45%)range miss
KRBN fell 6.45% over the week, breaching the lower end of the 33.40-36.45 forecast range. The abstained direction was appropriate given the stated uncertainty, but the realized move was larger than the assumed moderate 4-5% weekly envelope. As a single ETF-proxy outcome, this is weak evidence by itself and does not establish a repeatable range-calibration problem.
Next month to Nov 21 · said abstain 29.75-38.50 → actual 32.65 (-4.00%)range hit
KRBN finished at 32.65, down 4.0% from the forecast origin, while the forecast deliberately abstained on direction. The 29.75–38.50 one-month range contained the outcome, with a modest 4.32% error versus the midpoint. This single range hit does not reveal a repeatable mechanism beyond ordinary ETF and compliance-market noise.
Next day to Nov 21 · said abstain 31.30-33.70 → actual 32.65 (+0.03%)range hit
The next-day KRBN price was essentially unchanged at 32.65 versus 32.64, while the forecast abstained on direction and used a widened 31.30-33.70 range. The outcome landed well inside the range and very close to the midpoint, so the widened volatility allowance was sufficient without revealing a directional edge. This is only one quiet follow-through after a large prior move, so it does not establish a repeatable mechanism.
Government carbon pricing
CBAM certificate price (Q3 2026)
82.32 EUR/t
no daily change published
European Commission via CBAM Guide · as of 10/5/2026
EU ETS daily reference price
80.60 EUR/t
no daily change published
CBAM Guide (cbamguide.com) · as of 11/20/2026
EU ETS allowance (EUA)
77.44 EUR/t
-7.82%
SparkChange Physical Carbon ETC (CO2.L) · as of 11/22/2026
JurisdictionInstrumentRate (local)USD / tonneEmissions coveredYear
UruguayCO2 tax on motor fuels tax6900 UYU1676%2025
SwitzerlandCO2 levy on heating and process fuels tax120 CHF14733%2025
LiechtensteinCO2 levy tax120 CHF14779%2025
SwedenCarbon tax tax1490 SEK13740%2025
NorwayCO2 tax on mineral products tax1176 NOK11063%2025
European UnionEU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) ets80.00 EUR87.0039%2026
NetherlandsIndustry carbon levy tax78.67 EUR85.0012%2025
FinlandCarbon tax on transport and heating fuels tax77.00 EUR83.0036%2025
SwitzerlandSwiss ETS ets65.00 CHF80.0011%2025
IrelandCarbon tax tax63.50 EUR69.0049%2025
Northwest Territories, CanadaTerritorial carbon tax tax95.00 CAD69.0080%2025
British Columbia, CanadaBC output-based pricing (industry) ets95.00 CAD69.0025%2025
Alberta, CanadaTIER (industrial emitters) ets95.00 CAD69.0055%2025
Canada (federal)Output-Based Pricing System (industry) ets95.00 CAD69.0037%2025
PortugalCarbon tax tax57.00 EUR62.0029%2025
AustriaNational ETS for heating and transport ets55.00 EUR60.0040%2025
GermanyNational ETS for heating and transport (nEHS) ets55.00 EUR60.0040%2025
Washington, USAWashington Cap-and-Invest ets55.00 USD55.0075%2026
United KingdomUK Emissions Trading Scheme (UK ETS) ets40.00 GBP52.0025%2026
LuxembourgCarbon tax tax45.00 EUR49.0065%2025
FranceCarbon component of energy taxes tax44.60 EUR48.0035%2025
DenmarkCarbon tax on industry tax300 DKK43.0035%2025
IcelandCarbon tax on fossil fuels tax5000 ISK36.0055%2025
IsraelCarbon tax on fuels tax130 ILS36.0080%2025
New ZealandNZ ETS ets58.00 NZD35.0049%2026
California, USACalifornia Cap-and-Trade ets30.50 USD30.5075%2026
Quebec, CanadaQuebec Cap-and-Trade ets42.00 CAD30.5078%2026
MontenegroMontenegro ETS ets24.00 EUR26.0027%2025
RGGI (11 US states)Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative ets25.00 USD25.0017%2026
United KingdomCarbon Price Support tax18.00 GBP23.0021%2025
AustraliaSafeguard Mechanism ets35.00 AUD23.0028%2025
SpainTax on fluorinated greenhouse gases tax20.00 EUR22.003%2025
SingaporeCarbon tax tax25.00 SGD19.0080%2025
SloveniaCO2 tax tax17.30 EUR19.0047%2025
Zacatecas, MexicoState carbon tax tax350 MXN19.0012%2025
LatviaCarbon tax tax15.00 EUR16.0015%2025
South AfricaCarbon tax tax236 ZAR13.0080%2025
ChinaNational ETS ets70.00 CNY9.8040%2026
South KoreaK-ETS ets9000 KRW6.5074%2026
ColombiaNational carbon tax tax26000 COP6.3024%2025
Tokyo, JapanTokyo Cap-and-Trade Programme ets800 JPY5.3020%2025
ChileCarbon tax on large stationary sources tax5.00 USD5.0030%2025
Saitama, JapanSaitama Target Setting Emissions Trading ets700 JPY4.6018%2025
MexicoFederal carbon tax on fossil fuels tax78.00 MXN4.2023%2025
BotswanaCarbon tax tax50.00 BWP3.7010%2025
IndonesiaPower sector ETS (IDX Carbon) ets60000 IDR3.7014%2025
Estado de Mexico, MexicoState carbon tax tax43.00 MXN2.3011%2025
Queretaro, MexicoState carbon tax tax40.00 MXN2.2010%2025
EstoniaCO2 tax on stationary sources tax2.00 EUR2.206%2025
JapanTax for climate change mitigation tax289 JPY1.9075%2025
Tamaulipas, MexicoState carbon tax tax30.00 MXN1.608%2025
Guanajuato, MexicoState carbon tax tax30.00 MXN1.608%2025
Yucatan, MexicoState carbon tax tax30.00 MXN1.608%2025
Durango, MexicoState carbon tax tax30.00 MXN1.609%2025
Baja California, MexicoState carbon tax tax30.00 MXN1.608%2025
ArgentinaCarbon tax on liquid fuels tax1400 ARS1.2020%2025
KazakhstanKazakhstan ETS ets550 KZT1.1042%2025
UkraineCO2 emissions tax tax30.00 UAH0.7271%2025
PolandEmissions fee tax0.36 PLN0.094%2025
MexicoNational ETS (pilot phase) etsnot yet priced--40%2025
BrazilSBCE national ETS etsnot yet priced----2026
European UnionEU ETS2 (buildings and road transport) etsnot yet priced----2027
IndiaCarbon Credit Trading Scheme etsnot yet priced----2026
TurkeyNational ETS etsnot yet priced----2026
59 priced instruments shown. Statutory rates change once or twice a year, so they are reference figures, not a live feed, last checked 9/14/2026. USD conversions are indicative. Source: World Bank Carbon Pricing Dashboard. Live EU prices: Source: CBAM Guide (cbamguide.com) and SparkChange Physical Carbon ETC.
Carbon credits & allowances
Allowance and offset markets tracked here. Average move today -5.07% - the price of emitting fell.
KRBN-6.45%
KraneShares Global Carbon
32.65
GRN-7.72%
iPath Carbon ETN
32.52
KEUA--
KraneShares European Carbon Allowance
--
building history…
KCCA-1.04%
KraneShares California Carbon Allowance
17.36
KSET--
KraneShares Global Carbon Offset Strategy
--
building history…
Clean energy
ICLN-12.46%
iShares Global Clean Energy
13.84
TAN-18.44%
Invesco Solar
33.97
FAN-9.37%
First Trust Global Wind
20.43
QCLN-15.76%
First Trust Clean Edge Green Energy
36.87
PBW-17.31%
Invesco WilderHill Clean Energy
20.69
Fossil energy
XLE-6.85%
Energy Select Sector (fossil)
60.51
XOP-9.06%
Oil & Gas Exploration & Production
168.06
Energy inputs
TTF=F+3.57%
Dutch TTF Natural Gas
88.45
NG=F+16.83%
Henry Hub Natural Gas
3.75
CL=F-3.02%
WTI Crude Oil
83.41
Transition materials
LIT-11.54%
Global X Lithium & Battery Tech
51.98
URA-15.86%
Global X Uranium
26.79
REMX-15.91%
VanEck Rare Earth & Strategic Metals
42.06
ESG & green finance
BGRN+0.52%
iShares USD Green Bond
46.02
ESGU-8.52%
iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA
150.96
SUSA-8.17%
iShares MSCI USA ESG Select
142.24
Utilities
XLU-3.07%
Utilities Select Sector
42.69
Market baseline
^GSPC-8.61%
S&P 500
6910.39
Policy & market headlines
Ranked by relevance to carbon pricing and climate finance, most relevant first.
6
5
5
5
ESG regulation & disclosure· 2d agodisclosuregreen finance
5
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
ESG regulation & disclosure· 2d agodisclosuregreen finance
4
4
3
3
3
3
ESG regulation & disclosure· 14h 17m agodisclosuregreen finance
3
KRBN and GRN are exchange-traded proxies holding allowance futures, not EU ETS settlement prices — they carry tracking error and fund-flow noise. Use ICAP or Ember settlement data for written work.